For the Business and for the People

Article by Dr. John E. Kello

I am a heavy consumer of books and articles on successful organizations. Given the sheer volume of such works, I certainly can’t claim to have read all (or even most) of them. But I freely confess that my “pleasure reading” consists mostly of devouring the current writings on how-to in business. Reflecting on the current batch, I am struck by the reality that much of the writing focuses either on business strategy or on people strategy, as though they are independent, either-or alternatives. Few focus on the necessary interdependence of business strategy and people-leadership strategy for a best in show organization.

As but one very recent example, a colleague sent me a link to an article by a Stanford Business school professor, focusing on corporate cultures that drive growth. The interesting article identifies “adaptability” as the key to business growth, financial performance, and overall business success. According to the author, corporate cultures that support experimentation, risk-taking, and rapid reconfiguration around new opportunities are the most successful. I wouldn’t argue against those conclusions. Agility, scanning the environment surrounding the business, capitalizing on opportunities to increase market penetration, etc., are all important elements of an overall successful business. They may well be necessary, but they are not in and of themselves sufficient. They capture only a part of the puzzle. As an aside, I would also submit that many more organizations claim to support innovation and risk taking than actually do so. I know of more than a few examples of companies which have those affirming “words on the wall”, but which in fact are more prone to punish than to reward well-intentioned but unsuccessful experiments. A topic perhaps for another time.

Interestingly, the colleague who sent me the article is an executive in a truly excellent company, one that is very explicit about its “Culture of High Performance”. And their culture is stated in terms that highlight the treatment of people, the soft side of the culture. Mutual trust and respect, open communication, and positive assumptions are identified as keys to organizational success. I happen to know that this company is also a very strong business-strategy player. But they do not identify only the “hard business” side of the success equation. They clearly identify, and indeed highlight, the people-side of the equation as well.

My many years of research and practice in Organization Development have convinced me that successful organizations must be built jointly on effective business principles and positive people principles, and the more explicit they are about both, the better. As far back as the 1930s and 1940s, organizational theorists began to recognize the joint technical-and-social nature of work. Up until that time (and well beyond), many organizations ran in an assembly-line manner, with major focus on the technical production process and relatively little attention to the human element. The mindset: design an efficient production process and people will plug in and run it as extensions of the machine. But studies of the “traditional factory” gradually shifted attention toward the previously largely neglected human factor in the workplace. If employees are bored and have no say in how things are done, it is unlikely that many of them will be highly motivated. The “boredom of the factory” can result in poor business performance, even if employees are working with good equipment in a well-designed production process.

The iconic best in show companies that get so much press these days (mostly deserved I believe) do commonly exhibit a blend of both smart business strategy and smart people strategy. While different articles might emphasize business strategy over people-leadership strategy, or vice versa, the leaders of the pack most often emphasize both in an integrated way.

There is an older literature on leadership which parallels this overall business strategy discussion. Researchers and practitioners gradually recognized decades ago that a leader’s focus either on task (“initiating structure”) or on relationships (“showing consideration”) represented a false dichotomy. The most effective leaders focused on both. They got results and engaged their associates, instead of choosing one emphasis to the exclusion of the other.

Think of it this way. Could a hypothetical organization build an excellent business model, streamline production, do masterful marketing, and be successful in the long term even if it consistently treated its employees badly? At the other extreme, is it possible that an organization could build a successful high-involvement, pro-employee workplace, and be a great place to work (at least for a while) even if it did not attend to the needs of the business? In the long term (even intermediate term), neither extreme would forecast success. There may be exceptions (older stories about Steve Jobs’ leadership style at Apple and more recent stories about some elements of life at Amazon may suggest so), but they would truly be significant exceptions.

It is widely known that union-management relationships can be (and often are) challenging. A central reason is that, in “traditional” organizations, management has historically focused on the needs of the business (in fairness, it is their critical responsibility) and has been less concerned with the needs of the people. In contrast, the union has historically focused on the needs of the people (also in fairness, their primary responsibility) and has been less concerned with the needs of the business. With such different objectives, it is little wonder that union-management relationships can be strained.

Take a familiar example. Management needs to crew for some critical overtime work, to meet customer needs. Supervisors offer the overtime to associates who are there and can stay over to address the urgent need. They are focusing on the needs of the business. But the contract specifies that overtime will be offered to qualified associates based on seniority. If a supervisor “jumps the list”, intentionally or unintentionally, that is in violation of the contract. It is a trigger for a grievance, which may ultimately involve pay for those senior employees who were bypassed. The union is focused on protecting the rights of its people.

Where union-management relationships have been improved, the prevailing model has become business and people, jointly emphasized by both “sides”. The true, functioning union-management partnerships of which I am aware are predicated on this “both, not either-or” proposition.

Much of my research and consulting has focused on occupational safety, on creating a safe and sustainable workplace. Is a company’s safety focus driven by a concern for people? I expect that all of us would reply strongly in the affirmative. Is their focus driven by a concern for the business? Here the reply might not be quite as clear and strong, as it can come across as insensitive and inhumane to “put a price tag on safety”. But injuries negatively impact the business as well, in terms of measurable direct and indirect costs. I would submit that safety is an illustrative example of the essential nature of a joint people-and-business focus. It is one of the reasons that joint safety work is a starting point that I commonly recommend for improving contentious, adversarial union-management relationships. Such joint work in an area of such obvious common interest can lead to a deeper understanding of the people factor on the part of management and the business factor on the part of the union.

The bottom line is this: organizations that explicitly and jointly address the needs of the business and the needs of the people are best positioned for success. It’s just not an either-or proposition.

Next
Next

Working with Jerks